24 Frames Media

Cutting Room

Cutting Room: Google Is Running Two Search Engines at Once

AI Mode has passed a billion monthly users, while the classic results page keeps its map, its listings and its adverts. A local business now needs to be chosen by both, and the two choose differently.

On Sunday evening, 15 November, we typed four everyday searches into Google from Bath: a bakery, an interior designer, a plumber and a hairdresser. We ran each one twice. Once on the ordinary results page that everyone knows, with its map, its listings and its adverts. Then again in AI Mode, the tab where Google writes an answer instead of showing a list.

Same company, same searches, same evening. The two pages did not agree about who to show. And for a local business, that disagreement matters more than any single ranking, because a customer can now meet you, or miss you, in either place.

The map names three. The answer names eight.

On the ordinary page, each search led with the familiar map and three businesses beneath it. AI Mode did something quite different. It wrote a short introduction, grouped the businesses into kinds (period specialists and full-service studios for interior design; emergency plumbers and boiler engineers for plumbing) and named far more of them.

SearchBusinesses on the mapBusinesses in AI ModeOn the map and in AI Mode
bakery in Bath383 of 3
interior designer in Bath393 of 3
plumber in Bath362 of 3
hairdresser in Bath383 of 3
Total123111 of 12

Two things stand out. First, being on the map was a good sign: eleven of the twelve businesses the map showed were also named in AI Mode. Second, AI Mode opened the door much wider. It named twenty businesses that the map did not show at all. For a business that has never cracked the top three on the map, that is a real opening.

The one business that dropped out is worth a look. In the plumbing search, the map showed a plumber with a perfect five-star rating from 24 reviews. AI Mode left it out. Every plumber AI Mode did name had at least 69 reviews. Four searches cannot prove why, but the pattern points one way: the answer seems to want more to go on than a short run of perfect scores.

Adverts behaved differently too. On the ordinary page, the interior design search carried sponsored businesses above the map, a sponsored listing inside it and sponsored results lower down. In AI Mode, one of those advertisers also appeared in the written answer, with no sponsored label beside it. The bakery search carried two sponsored results on the ordinary page; the plumbing and hairdressing searches carried none that we could see.

The answer is written from what you have already published

Read what AI Mode says about each business and you notice that it is not inventing anything. It describes an interior designer by its "Georgian, Regency, and listed period homes" speciality, a bakery by its cardamom buns and its open view of the lamination room, and a plumber by its hours and its phone number. These are facts a business has already put somewhere: on its Google Business Profile, on its website, in the words of its reviews.

That is the most useful thing a local business can take from the test. The words you use to describe yourself on your profile and your website are, more and more, the words Google uses to describe you to a customer. If your profile says "interior designer" and nothing else, there is nothing for the answer to repeat. If it says what you specialise in, which areas you cover and when you are open, the answer has something to work with.

Google is building both, and taking its time

Why would Google run two such different pages side by side? Because it is moving search towards written answers while keeping the page that pays for it. At its developer conference in May, Google said AI Mode had passed one billion monthly users, gave it a new default model and redesigned the search box, the biggest change to it in more than 25 years. Questions typed into AI Mode run two to three times longer than ordinary searches.

Yet the ordinary page still carries most searches. One clickstream study put AI Mode below 0.2% of desktop search events in the United States in the first quarter of 2026. Google is also bringing adverts into the answer gradually: it announced shopping adverts in AI Mode in February. And in early November a searcher reported a Google search bar without the AI Mode button; Google has not confirmed a test. The direction is clear. The pace is careful.

The ordinary page is changing as well. Since January, trackers have reported mobile searches showing an AI-written version of the local map in place of the familiar three businesses, and trackers report that it often names fewer businesses and leaves out the call button. We did not see that in Bath. None of our searches, including "what is the best bakery in Bath", showed an AI Overview at the top of the ordinary page. For now, here, the map still makes the first impression, and AI Mode gives the second opinion.

Be found in both

The good news is that the two pages reward much the same work. Both lean on the Google Business Profile. Both reward reviews. Both pick up the facts a business publishes about itself. A few things matter most:

  • A complete, verified Business Profile. The map uses it directly, and AI Mode quotes from it.
  • A steady flow of reviews. In our plumbing search, every business AI Mode named had at least 69.
  • Your specialities in your own words, on the profile and on your website. AI Mode repeats them almost word for word.
  • Accurate hours and a working phone number. AI Mode printed both for every plumber it named.
  • Readiness for a new button. Three of our four AI Mode answers ended with "Check appointments for me", which offers to get availability and prices from local businesses and book the right one. Businesses that can answer that question quickly will be easier to choose.

A 15-minute test to run on your phone tonight

  1. Write down five searches a customer would make to find you, such as "florist in Bath" or "wedding cake Bath".
  2. Run each one on the ordinary Google page and note whether you appear on the map.
  3. Tap the AI Mode tab and run it again. Note whether you are named, and which words Google uses to describe you.
  4. Check that the hours and phone number in the answer are right.
  5. Wherever the answer describes a competitor in detail and you not at all, look at what that competitor has published that you have not.

How we tested: four searches and one follow-up question, run on 15 November 2026 from Bath in a signed-in Chrome browser, on the ordinary results page and in AI Mode. Google tailors results to the person, the place and the time, so your results will differ. We have not named the businesses that appeared.